I've been to Hailey's several times and always found it very inviting and familiar. As a Brit living in the US, Hailey's is about the closest I've found to a traditional British (and presumably, Irish) pub, locally. The food is always on point and being able to get such staples as bangers and mash or shepherd's pie is a huge draw for me, personally. The extensive beer selection is frequently rotated, which is really appreciated, while the cocktails are also excellent and reasonably priced. I always find the staff to be very friendly and professional, really seeming to enjoy their work. To date, I haven't had a bad experience at Hailey's and would highly recommend them to anybody seeking a modestly priced dining experience with a distinctly European flair.

Went here for my boyfriend's sister's birthday, and it was a vibe! Chill atmosphere, live music, and awesome quotes on the wall. The service was top-notch.Thierry (our waiter) was fantastic. We ordered a mix of dishes, from fish & chips to shepherd's pie and Guinness chicken (which my boyfriend's mom called 'divine'). Portions were huge—everyone had leftovers except me (French onion soup was too good!). Overall, it was an amazing experience. Highly recommend!

Hailey’s is a great small-town Irish pub. The atmosphere is very festive and upbeat. The walls are well-decorated, there are plenty of TVs, there’s a large bar area, and there are plenty of special event nights. The menu is pretty large with traditional Irish pub food and drinks. I ordered the shepherds pie, which is their signature dish. This included ground lamb and beef, carrots, celery, onions, peas, cheddar cheese, and mashed potatoes. Everything blended together well and tasted great. The prices were also very reasonable. It’s no wonder this restaurant is a Metuchen stable. I highly recommend dining here.

Hailey's is an excellent Irish Pub. We've been coming to Hailey's since they opened. They have consistently good food and service. They offer an excellent selection of draft beer and maintain their taps well. Their bartenders are professional and they offer a nice array of cocktails. We enjoy most everything on the menu, especially the Irish fare such as the Irish soda bread, shepherd's pie and corned beef and cabbage. The Chicken Milanese is also a favorite. They frequently have live music. Outdoor seating is available weather permitting. Metuchen is a lovely town with an award winning Main Street. Hailey's is an asset to the community. The staff is friendly and great to deal with.

A hidden gem in the heart of Metuchen. The restaurant is a few steps from the train station. The wait staff was remarkable and the food (I ordered wings) did not disappoint! I’ve found a new place when in the area.

We came for the first time on St. Patrick’s Day for dinner and our experience was fantastic. The fish and chips were some of the best I’ve had since moving to NJ from NYC, the service was impeccable and everyone who works here is so pleasant, also, the environment is chill yet fun. Highly recommend and will definitely be coming back.

Always a favorite. Their food is reliably good. The staff is super nice. The drinks are delicious. It can get loud, but it is a bar, so to be expected. They have live music, trivia, and other entertainment. Definitely a fan favorite.

Helped us host a fundraiser in the back room. Great environment. Energy. Food. Service. We’re lucky to have a place like this around. Can’t work with better nicer people.